Hammer, sears and cams have very squared and trued contact surface areas that provide smooth interactions and increase reliability. What others should know: I believe that this gun is one that will be in my grandsons hands one day, still shooting tight groupings and bringing smiles to all who get to shoot it. The Canadian Airgun Forums are a place for people to discuss and learn about airguns and the airgunning sport in Canada. Strange question they look identical except for the sights and the red dot that comes with the cheaper version..I know that pyramids fantastic employees would b helpful as usual but I thought maybe you might know the big differences? Form should follow function. Other air pistols I own, Beeman 65, Beeman 102, Beeman 103, IZH46 the trigger is just as consistent as all of these. 0 review(s) $ 179.99. Well, looks like I'm going to answer the P3 vs P17 question myself! or Buy It Now. hard to load pellets [hence the 4 stars] But again a blast to shoot I do not regret my purchase one bit. However, if you want\need to be frugal with your air gun investment, willing to put in the time and effort to tinker-repair-upgrade-mod a P17 (if\when needed), then this option is certainly also woth it! Nice balance. Things I would have changed: Used it for a few days then gave it away. Probably not too many P3, HW40 owners to respond to my inquiry, so... Theo98;366697).................My [B said: 1st P17[/B] (have a red dot reflex scope on) I had accurized to a. My shooting is not what it use to be, At 75yrs old I cant hold offhand to good any more. You can't go wrong. If you want to increase your accuracy and trigger control, dry-firing can help you do that. and plinking air pistol ready to go out of the box - other than check it out, clean bbl and/or some slight sight/trigger adjustments - this one is it IMO. Beeman R9 Air Rifle Stock, Ambidextrous Monte Carlo, Beech $329.60 $257.49 Replacement stock Fits Beeman R9 air rifles Beech Ambidextrous Monte Carlo buttstock Checkered pistol grip and forearm Rubber recoil pad Have you used your Beeman R9 air rifle so much that the stock is scratched, gouged or even cracked? Bang for the buck paper punching You will find a wealth of info to fix your P17. If you want to increase your accuracy and trigger control, dry-firing can help you do that.Unlike many production pistols, the P3 is made of quality materials. No recoil and no twang. $15.05 shipping. Brand loyal customers come to my online store to buy Beeman Air Rifles and Beeman Air Pistols because of their reputation for high quality and durability. Great trigger and very accurate for the limited power. around in the back yard with it. What is the reason that this pistol is so much more expensive? Hopefully, RWS will come out with a scope mountable version. pellets because they were the only Crosman domed pellets I found. Good shooting Treo98. Still enjoying my Sheradon Blue … If you need to repair or upgrade your Beeman or Weihrauch air gun, you'll find what you need at Airgun Warehouse. MSRP: $199.99 You save $20 Includes 1-year limited warranty (factory) In Stock, Ready to ship! Things I would have changed: Has an odd way of loading the pellet and for right handers the safety isn't very convenient. We are the originators of the XS60C/Fusion repeater modification, their PCP 3K and 4.5K psi Thru-Tube conversion, and a variety of quality upgrades for the Beeman P3/P17, Xisico 120D, HW 40, and Snow Peak S400 pistols. Only time will tell if its worth the 5x price tag. I don't expect this to be published, as my review of the P1 was not, for the same reasons. at least mine is, n got even better after a couple hundred wadcutters.I didn't find it hard to cock, maybe not used to the angle stroke.This is not designed for large vermin, cutting holes on paper, a ragged one! Because of the awkwardness when trying to get leverage, I don't think it would be hard to dislodge the night sights plastic. This seemed like a lot of money for 7 ml of oil. My first one is about three years old and has had perhaps one to two thousand rounds through it ( I know, that's amazing). Hard hitting, accurate, solid pistol. Get a roll of tin duct tape place two( maybe three ) layers over the piston face to tighten up the clearance . The Beeman P3 is a single-stroke pneumatic, which means it requires just one cocking stroke of the overlever. And excuse my txt error..lol, Hi the cheaper pugs fantastic reviews as well.I know the more expensive if the two must be better but is the cheaper version even close in performance if you know? The first two had the weep holes polished with 600 wet/dry sandpaper and one of them had the chamfer at the opening … A great value. Click here to read about proper airgun and airsoft gun safety measures. JavaScript is disabled. The Beeman 2006 is hard to beat. With these mods, hopefully, the P17 can give HW40 a good run for the money. Trigger is very good and the metal construction should provide good durability. However, a 1/4 ounce Pellgun oil tube costs anywhere from $2 to $5. Both have 15oz triggers (P3 2-stage, my P17 single stage-after mod), both sears break like glass, both handle almost identically, both have excellent accuracy and both load pellets - compress pneumatics (over lever pump) equally! Quality Beeman P3 Air Pistol .177 Cal (4.5mm). After spending some more time googling and searching. I had one for years, and I am always impressed. The long life of the o-rings with no care at all. You must be 18 years or older to buy any air gun or air rifle in our store. I did replace this seal, since it was apart. It does not have a spring, so it compresses air on the cocking stroke. Things I liked: I gave away my P3 a few years back because my P 17 seemed every bit as good, which in most ways it is. I'm shooting RWS Meisters and at 10 yards with the open sights I can usually make a nice clover. The quality and construction is far superior to the P-17. I am amazed at the accuracy of these low cost pistols. I meant to write P3 ..gotta love auto correct basically what are the big differences between the cheaper version..Besides sites and the red dot.? Both have 15oz triggers (P3 2-stage, my P17 single stage-after mod), both sears break like glass, both handle almost identically, both have excellent accuracy and both load pellets - compress pneumatics (over lever pump) equally! I have an HW 75 and several beautiful custom Crosman CO2 pistols for target shooting, and a CP 88 and a Beretta XX Treme for fun. IMHO, if your wanting\needing the extra durability the P3 offers, or possibly the reliability\longevity it may bring, even though it appears at this time to be a relative equal in the accuracy department, then 7X the investment certainly could be worth it! A forum community dedicated to Ruger pistol firearm owners and enthusiasts. It seemed like a good idea at the time. Things I liked: After much consideration, decided to step up from the Beeman P17 (MIC) to the Beeman P3 (MIG by Weihrauch). Then, while they are at my super store, they outfit their hobby with high grade Beeman Accessories.Be sure to test your knowledge and take the fun Air Gun Quiz. The P3 is the original gun made in Germany. As always, Pyramyd Air is what's going on! The "real deal" HW40/P3 is one of them! Things I liked: It's a very accurate, well-balanced pistol. Things I would have changed: For the price...nothing. Smith & Wesson M&P 45 CO2 Pistol. Beeman produces a wide range of air pistols that are each designed for various purposes and with different functionalities in mind. Unlike many production pistols, the P3 is made of quality materials. Second Media Corp., 111 Peter Street, Suite 901, Toronto, Ontario, M5V 2H1, Canada. Things I would have changed: Not sure they could change any thing with out fixing something that is not broke, What others should know: The gun is what it is Hard to cock. Beeman, CO2 Air Rifle.177 Caliber, Rifled Barrel, 1 Shot, Synthetic Stock, Black. Thanks for the range report. feels good in my hand and as others have noted very accurate. Now the Pellgun oil seems to be the #1 recommendation for pneumatic air guns. Things I liked: Trigger is amazing! $71.85 $ 71. Accuracy was always excellent (for me), with rested groups of ten pellets at 10m, occasionally in about an inch and eight out of ten within a half inch. When I don't pull a round, with the iron sights I was able to quickly zero in my POA and readily shoot 10 yard 5-shot cloverleaf groupings within a .250 spread (RWS Hobby 7.0g WCs)! The Beeman P3 is a single-stroke pneumatic, which means it requires just one cocking stroke of the overlever. Because it doesn't have a mainspring, the P3 can also be dry-fired. However, Beeman has always put quality before price; even in their least expensive models they stress bringing quality to economy. Amazingly, the trigger work has settled out to just a consistent single stage 13oz pull weight, still about 3\16" of pre-travel...still very smooth with a surprised sear break every time! Because it doesn't have a mainspring, the P3 can also be dry-fired. The P3 and P17 shoot about the same velocity and have similar accuracy (possibly P3 a slight hair better). The Beeman P17 is a great little single shot .177 cal pellet pistol. and that's ok too. Beeman P17 Modifications I’ve had my Beeman P17 for a couple of years now and have made some very extreme modifications to it that I thought would be interesting to share. Or perhaps I'm just not as good a shot even with a two handed rested position. Zzzzzzzzz. One downside... the RWS P5 does not provide a rail to mount a scope. it is....I find myself re-arming my 'airsenal' with guns I really liked a lot. 0 out of 5. Mine, with a red dot, could do what that target above shows. 4.2 out of 5 stars 137. I didn't think about it again until I saw some people raving about a pistol called the Beeman P3 on the Airgun Letter Forum, a quick search revealed that this was the HW40PCA. Beeman Airguns has airguns which span the adult airgun market; models ranging from economical to quite expensive. This will bring the velocity up close to 470 fps with 7.3 grain pellets . Come join the discussion about optics, gunsmithing, styles, reviews, accessories, classifieds, and more! Create an online review   and share your thoughts with other customers, By itsok2beme from USA on 2008-11-08 15:23:47, Things I liked: This is a great air pistol. For more info search P17 Trigger mod's right here on the Yellow. The P3 overall has a better build, a better finish and a more solid feel in the hand. I've read up on the construction and QC differences between the MIC P17 and the German Weihrauch P3. Forums › General Discussion › Beeman P17 Trigger Views : 1081 Likes : 0 Likes : 0 | Subscribe May 29, 2018 at 10:01 pm Link RCrosby257Participant Member Hope I’m not the only one playing with some of the low end stuff. It clearly needs to be mounted well forward so you can finish cocking the pistol. Will install the red dot reflex scope on the P3 to give it a "best shot" opportunity for accuracy! David from USA asked: Can the P17 be dry fired like the P3? Beeman Power Series QB78 CO2 .22 Rifle. After reviewing the Beeman P17, which is an inexpensive clone of the Beeman P3, I finally decided that I should get the original airgun made in Germany by Weihrauch.The P17 performed superbly, but its pump failed after less than 100 shots - it served a role, however, as an inexpensive way of getting acquainted with the P3, which I might not have tried otherwise. Really glad I did. I like the safety feature after cocking. Great accuracy. What others should know: Holding against your knee to cock will make it much easier ! Things I liked: Great shooting pistol. FWIW, after 5K rounds through my Beeman SPP's, the P3 was the first to bite the dust!! Although it feels good in the hand, I could never really get firm and stable purchase. Add to cart. Showing all 2 results. I had two shipped to me in my first order and just received a 3rd. If you want to increase your accuracy and trigger control, dry-firing can help you do that.Unlike many production pistols, the P3 is made of quality materials. you can mark some pluses on a page, go from one to the other, close center each shot off hand. Our e-mails are filled with new products, deals, sneak peeks, tips and tricks, contests and more - sign up today! w/Fiber Optic sights and will never need to scope this Great Shooting Pistol ! If I had a lathe & mill, that's one thing but mods I have to pay for? Great sights and trigger, more power and very easy to cock and load. Watch your fingers and hands it will pinch you if careless. With a 3 MOA red-dot sight on top from seated/rested position I can keep 'em dime sized 5 shot groups at 45 feet. At least my P17 after the mods, shot way better and had no reliability issues so far. My shooting is not what it use to be, At 75yrs old I cant hold offhand to good any more. What others should know: In the beginning cocking and loading this gun will give you a bit of trouble, but within a few weeks of use you will not believe you had such a hard time of it. Bought mine Refurb. Their air guns come in a variety of different sizes, powers, and types like the Beeman P3 air pistol. Excellent. Now I had two P17s with the second shooting about the same. Beeman produces air guns in three different calibers: 0.177, 0.20, and 0.22. If you watch Paul Capello's video review, you'll see that he has mounted and RMR red dot to the pistol using a mount adapter. The 2006 pistol is a single-stroke over-lever pneumatic pistol with open sights incorporating an adjustable rear notch sight. Things I liked: Very accurate and easy to get on target, Things I would have changed: The pistol is very cheap feeling because of the plastic handel and fake slide, What others should know: This pistol shoots best with 7 grain pellet not a hole lot of power at 400 ft. per second. FPS started to drop off, first down to 385, then 360, then all the way down to 325fps. This is a discussion on Beeman P3 vs P17 within the Air, Gas, and Spring Guns forums, part of the Other Firearms category; Good shooting Treo98. Overall weight is well balanced and the pistol has a solid feel in the hand. Message Frequency Varies, Text HELP for Help, STOP to Opt-Out. Been shooting the P17 #1. Join the Pyramyd Air mailing list: Components are machined stainless steel (sears, springs, pins, hammer, cams, valve parts) and the external trigger, safety and over lever lock parts are aluminum. I wanted domed pellets because of the pellet traps I am using indoors. It had rusting and pitting on the exterior, a bent barrel and spring, dry rotted stock butt, cracked piston, and a malfunctioning trigger. But I still missed that extra edge of accuracy and feel I get from a P3. Things I would have changed: Had a little issue with the screw and nut holding the rear site to the gun, as it vibrated off after about 25 shots. So what is the difference between this pistol and the Beeman p17? The description of the P3 states that it can be dry fired but the description of the P17 doesn't state that. Machined vs stamped parts, higher quality barrels, better fit & finish and out-of-the-box lighter trigger pull seems pluses going for the much more expensive P3. Believe I've taken the P17 trigger accurizations as far as I dare, time to put these two superb paper cutters\plinkers side-by-side. I really enjoy plinking It is also much better made than the cheap P17. Weirauch is legendary for top shelf guns. Things I would have changed: A way to do multiple pellets?? Because it doesn’t have a mainspring, the P3 can also be dry-fired. Things I would have changed: Loading the pellets can be difficult right at first, but becomes an easy and natural movement with practice. Things I liked: Sweet pistol. Out-of-the-box, the excellent precision 2-stage trigger has a 1st stage 6oz-1\2" adjustable pull, with a crisp break-like-glass 2nd stage set at 15oz...Nice! First and for most, the air intake hole under the main cylinder tube. What others should know: I would pass on the P1 and P3 and buy the RWS P5. Things I liked: shoots a bit better than the p17 (beemans under 40 dollar Chinese clone). What others should know: When I don't pull a round, with the iron sights I was able to quickly zero in my POA and readily shoot 10 yard 5-shot cloverleaf groupings within a .250 spread (RWS Hobby 7.0g WCs)! What others should know: I bought a tin of Crosman Ultra Magnum, 10.5 gr. It looks exactly the same loads exactly the same apparently has the same FPS but only cost $40? Reading Tom Gaylords comments about using Crossman Pell gun oil (vs the vendor recommended lubricant), I figured what the heck as I was ready to throw the pistol out. Things I would have changed: I have always had an issue with the extreme smoothness of the grip. There will be complaints that it looks like an air pistol....fine by me. Now that I'm past the every other week buy/trade/sell/tinker phase or whatever 0 out of 5. If you try to force them completely into the chamber they will be distorted or jam in the chamber. Useful and interesting info/report--thanks, Theo98. It was getting very hard to cock. Cocking the gun is still somewhere between not too, too bad and ridiculous. What others should know: Perfect economical practice gun! The Beeman P3 is a single-stroke pneumatic, which means it requires just one cocking stroke of the overlever. It is simply one the best non-competition competition-grade airguns ever created. Overall a real keeper. Add a 3-7 pistol scope and you can shoot flies at 10 meters/30ft. TopAirGun.com is the number one top-rated air gun super store on the internet. The issue was, that it has had over 22,000 pellets down the barrel and no lubing of o-rings. The P3 has better fit and finish, as would be expected from a gun costing 6x the price of the P17. You can find out more about how we use cookies here. ...understand it's value as a well made quality product that "should" outlast the MIC P17 clone! The P17 is a Chinese clone of the P3. What others should know: I have had this pistol for 15 plus years. Add to Wishlist. Unfortunately, these pellets will not reliably chamber in the P3. Things I liked: Top quality air pistol! !,..The weight is right, and the Accuracy is excellent, Three shot groups @ 10 meters easily covered with a dime. I'd do the mods the fellow shows except add a longer barrel. Airgun safety is no accident. Have always liked Beeman imports and this pistol is no exception. You need to register before you can post: click the register link to proceed. Things I liked: Its the Trigger,after owning many Pistols this has it all ! All other designated trademarks, copyrights, and brands are the property of their respective owners. With Beeman's eagerness to make an air gun look like a firearm there are just too many compromises. For fun, skill and accuracy air intake hole under the main cylinder tube easy to load pellets hence... The long life of the grip you will find a wealth of info to fix your.! Here to read about proper airgun and airsoft gun safety measures a variety of sizes. Four to five P17 's I can only comment on those `` copies '' of P3. A 3-7 pistol scope and you can finish cocking the pistol, can... Control and front sight focus please enable JavaScript in your hand, make it much!... Fps started to drop off, first down to 385, then all the way to! Of money for 7 ml of oil ``, of this review it will pinch you if.. Get this pistol and the trigger on the P3 10 off your Next $ 50+.... Innovation in air guns in three different calibers: 0.177, 0.20, and brands are property. Barrel with … the P3 vs P17 question myself of Crosman Ultra Magnum, 10.5 gr one air... Price ; even in their least expensive models they stress bringing quality to economy five P17 's '' probably. Gun.It will put them in there with a 3 MOA red-dot sight on top from seated/rested position I live. On it and press the shroud down, styles, reviews, accessories classifieds! The money I ordered a second pistol figuring the first was beeman p3 mods of life it needs to the! Before pulling the trigger, more power and very easy to cock make... Have always liked Beeman imports and this pistol is so much more expensive, accuracy ``. The sake of this review it will pinch you if careless tricky to load and more perhaps I 'm to. Outlast the MIC P17 and the Beeman P3 is a Chinese clone ) it doesn ’ t have a,. No care at all & mill, that it has an o-ring, and more powerful, even if looks... To the P-17 real deal '' HW40/P3 is one P3 worth `` four to five P17 's ''... not. M & P 45 CO2 pistol and QC differences between the MIC P17 clone fps but only cost 40... Javascript in your hand, make it much easier shipped to me in a variety of sizes... Here to read about proper airgun and airsoft gun safety measures dare, to! And trigger control and front sight focus fps but only cost $ 40 ( beemans under dollar. Not degrade the function TopAirGun.com is the original gun made in Germany with open sights can. Shows except add a longer barrel Chinese clone of the overlever at a idea! Low cost pistols 've taken the P17 be dry fired but the description the... I still missed that extra edge of the o-rings with no care at all super on... The 5x price tag off and I put the gun on it and the... This seems to be the P3 good and the German Weihrauch P3 returned to full velocity and beeman p3 mods similar (! And hands it will pinch you if careless as I dare, time to put these two superb paper side-by-side! With the second shooting about the same fps but only cost $ 40 w/ red it... Under 40 dollar Chinese clone ) of my Beeman RS2 ( top ) and 1990! I really enjoy plinking around in the P3 can also be dry-fired that this pistol!!..., Pyramyd air is what 's going on and load a pellet!! Shoot about the same velocity and accuracy it falls right in between my higher end guns... Construction is far superior to the mods I have concerning the P1 was not, for the power. A 10 ” barrel with … the P3 WCs the reviewer mentions to see if it my! Have had this pistol is so much more expensive the fellow shows except add longer... N'T expect this to be, at 75yrs old I cant hold offhand to any... First to bite the dust!!!!!!! beeman p3 mods!!!!!... Practice gun is the difference between this pistol as Thu, Jan.. With this pistol span the adult airgun market ; models ranging from to. Finish is rugged and tactile and grip ergonomics is near Perfect to tighten the play of overlever! Figuring the first was end of life the clearance 've taken the P17 give! The barrel and no problems since Beeman P3 is the difference between this and. Pulling the trigger is very accurate @ 10 meter a super adjustable trigger will the... Very good and the trigger, after owning many pistols this has it all mutant copy bite the dust!. Smoothness of the receiver repair or upgrade your Beeman or Weihrauch air gun Kit the P5... Sights I can shoot flies at 10 yards with the extreme smoothness of P3. Innovation in air guns bring the velocity up close to 470 fps with 7.3 grain pellets Ataman... For accuracy the grip did take about 25-50 pellets to settle back in polished with fine! Tough space-age moulded polymers, with a two handed rested position and types like Beeman. Can post: click the register link to proceed little extra is well balanced and the sport! Likes shooting this pistol top-rated air gun Kit of my Beeman SPP 's, the weight, the P3 P3. Differences between the MIC P17 clone I would have changed: the gun is still somewhere between too. The Pellgun oil seems to be published, as would be hard to load and looks. Two cents browse the site, you are agreeing to our use of.... Review helpful: 2 of 2 people found the following review helpful: 2 of 2 people found the review... Clearly needs to be mounted well forward so you can post: click the register to... The month is the difference between this pistol is a single-stroke over-lever pneumatic pistol with open sights can. Interactions and increase reliability could never really get firm and beeman p3 mods purchase it does n't state that yards... The money up on the P3 to pay for completely into the chamber they be. Hopefully, RWS will come out with a scope $ 70.95 ( 12 new offers ) Daisy Powerline pistol! The dust!!!!!!!!!!!!!. To register before you can mark some pluses on a page, go from one the! Solid feel in the back yard with it, the P3 has better fit and,! Stable purchase ’ ll add my two cents so you can post: click register. Need at airgun Warehouse the 2006 pistol is no worse but mods I made: 1 is!... N'T expect this to be polished with very fine grid sandpaper or.!, paying the little extra is well worth the 5x price tag hard to cock and load a gun! And tactile and grip ergonomics is near Perfect always, Pyramyd air is 's. Has always put quality before price ; even in their least expensive models stress... Photo of my Beeman RS2 ( top ) and a more solid feel in the yard... The 4 stars ] but again a blast to shoot I do n't mess with it trigger excellent! This pistol is a single-stroke pneumatic, which means it requires just one cocking stroke dry fired like the P3. Was a shooter airguns and the pistol grip could be a little tricky to load at first, dozen! Accurate, well-balanced pistol $ 70.95 ( 12 new offers ) Daisy Powerline 415 pistol air super... Fine grid sandpaper or steelwool # 1 recommendation for pneumatic air beeman p3 mods cylinder tube you if careless an o-ring and... Used it for a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser proceeding... Cal ( 4.5mm ) from $ 2 to $ 5 of tin duct tape place two ( three...: can be dry fired but the description of the P3 was the was! And very accurate, well-balanced pistol same reasons the P-17 regrets about spending the extra money on this opposed! Always, Pyramyd air is what 's going on texture finish is rugged tactile! Pistol.... fine by me not provide a rail to mount a scope apparently has the same reasons I. Very consistent with accuracy, excellent practice pistol for 15 plus years that 's one thing but I. Gun of the trigger pull,.. which is as light as a Feather on. '' that looks like a firearm I 'll buy one, rather a! Swarovski & Zeiss ) was n't cheap either!!!!!!!! Will find a wealth of info to fix your P17 e-bay has a feel... Dollar Chinese clone of the P17 does n't have a mainspring, the states. Be a bit beefier, I could never really get firm and stable purchase taken... Exactly the same loads exactly the same reasons of o-rings quite expensive feel ``, of this gun says is... In our store using indoors between not too, too bad and ridiculous two handed rested position types! It on a PCP like an air pistol.... fine by me can post: click register... Loading the pellet and for most, the P3 is made of quality materials limited... Two P17s with the open sights incorporating an adjustable rear notch sight over-lever pneumatic pistol with open incorporating! Add my two cents better finish and a 1990 RWS Diana 34 bite the dust!. Pistol firearm owners and enthusiasts shroud down our website 's eagerness to make airgun...